Newspaper Editorials
From Missouri Digital News:
MDN Menu

MDN Home

Journalist's Creed


MDN Help

MDN.ORG: Missouri Digital News
MDN Menu

MDN Home

Journalist's Creed


MDN Help

MDN.ORG Mo. Digital News Missouri Digital News MDN.ORG: Mo. Digital News MDN.ORG: Missouri Digital News

Newspaper Editorials

Date: November 13, 2008
By: Juana Summers
State Capitol Bureau
Links: The election results

JEFFERSON CITY - Editorial boards at some of Missouri's largest newspapers were vocal about their selections for the state's top offices, all of which were contested this year.  But in 2008, do editorial endorsements still matter and to what extent do they influence what voters do when they go to the polls?

Some studies tend to suggest that's not the case, and that voters are more likely to rely on their own knowledge when they cast their votes.

Earlier this year, the Pew Research Center for People and the Press released a study that compared the effects of various types of endorsements - from political figures, celebrities and religious leaders - alongside the endorsements made by local newspapers. 

The study found that endorsements by local newspapers would have a mixed impact on public opinion: 14 percent of those polled said a local newspaper endorsement would impact their vote positively and 14 percent said it would impact their vote negatively.  69 percent of respondents said the endorsement of their local newspaper wouldn't make a difference about their vote.

But Gilbert Bailon, editorial page editor for the St. Louis Post Dispatch, said the purpose of newspapers endorsing political candidates isn't always to change the way people vote. Instead, he said he thinks there is intellectual value in allowing newspaper readers to see the decision-making and rationale that comes along with choosing a candidate to support.

"I don't think that's the measure of a good editorial in a democratic society," he said. "Editorials make you think, they make you analyze. But that doesn't necessarily mean you're going to vote that way."

But Tina Hervey, spokesman for the Missouri Republican Party, said, this year, editorial endorsements reflect a growing bias in the media each year.

"I think every year, there's media bias," she said. "The Joplin Globe is in literally the most conservative city in the state, and they have never endorsed a Republican.The editorial endorsements are supposed to be a reflection of the communities that they serve."

She said, in terms of editorials, this year was strongly focused on Democrats, and this year isn't a good example of whether editorials mattered in the polling booth.

"I think it would be wiser to look at earlier years where it didn't seem to be as politically toxic for one party or not. if you look at this year, where it was clearly a Democrat year, and say the endorsements had some impact, that would be faulty in my opinion."

One of the state's top three newspapers, the Springfield News-Leader decided this year to only make endorsements in local races. In a signed letter from Don Wyatt, executive editor of the News-Leader Media Group, stated the reason was part of the paper's two-year effort to refocus on local coverage.

The paper did, however, run stories on statewide candidates that discussed their issues, and candidates were given the opportunity to write letters to a special section, discussing their qualifications for top offices. Then, Wyatt said, readers can make their own decisions.

"Our readers can sort it out," Wyatt wrote of the paper's decision to avoid statewide editorials.

The Columbia Missourian also does not make editorial endorsements.

Bailon, along with editors at some of the state's top newspapers, say editorials aren't about influencing voter behavior, they're about the process newspapers take to endorse a candidate and how they show that on the Opinion page.

For newspapers, endorsement is a difficult process, more complex than drawing a candidate's names out of a hat.  For Miriam Pepper, vice president of the Kansas City Star's editorial page, the process involves interviews and research.

"We review our previously published stories and the candidate statements, materials and Web sites and get together and discuss them," she said. 

The Star's editorial board is made up of nine people who also sit in on round-table interviews of many candidates for top offices.  The paper runs editorial endorsements for three weeks before an election.  But on the last week before the election, the paper holds off on overtly political letters or commentary.

"It's a fairness issue for the candidates, so they can have a chance to reply.  They wouldn't have a chance to reply to a Monday letter," she said.

Bailon said the St. Louis paper takes a similar approach, and that debate is one of the most important parts of the process.

"It's not always that everyone's views line up," he said. "You need to weigh in on not just what you like about the person you're endorsing,but also what you might not like."

From an academic perspective, writing editorials is about the mentality of a candidate.

"I think that many thoughtful voters turn to editorial endorsements to get a sense of what the candidates think," said Geneva Overholser, director of the Annenberg School of Journalism at the University of Southern California.  Overholser is a former MU faculty member.

"I think that hearing a viewpoint gives you a take on a candidate that is a little different than the straight news story, just the same way that people want to read opinion journalism," she said.

Overholser, who ran the editorial page at the Des Moines Register while she was editor there, said outside of partisan politics editorial writing and editorial endorsements play an important role in the community.

"It's part of what puts a face on newspapers," she said. "When newspapers quit endorsing, they are really abandoning an important role in the community, which is to take stands and to represent viewpoints on the editorial page, instead of just a detached news approach."

Missouri Newspaper Endorsements in the 2008 Election

Office Kansas City Star Saint Louis Post Dispatch Columbia Tribune Winner
Governor Jay Nixon (D) Jay Nixon (D) Jay Nixon (D) Jay Nixon (D)
Lieutenant Governor Sam Page (D) Sam Page (D) Neither * Peter Kinder (R)
Secretary of State Robin Carnahan (D) Robin Carnahan (D) Robin Carnahan (D) Robin Carnahan (D)
State Treasurer Clint Zwiefel (D) Clint Zwiefel (D) Clint Zweifel (D) Clint Zweifel (D)
Attorney General Mike Gibbons (R) Chris Koster (D) Mike Gibbons (R) Chris Koster (D)

* The Columbia Tribune recommended that a voter chose for lieutenant governor the candidate from the same party as the voter's choice for governor.